Many who know me will tell you that I was apprehensive about Man Of Steel for a good long while. I was pleased as punch for Henry Cavill, who I've thought was a bit of a dish since I saw him in The Tudors, but I was nervous about the movie overall. This was not helped when I discovered that the director of the movie was going to be Zack Snyder, who had previously not managed to impress me with 300 or Watchmen. I approached the movie with caution and refused to be excited about it nor anticipating it to be terrible. I was as open minded as I could be going in to see it.
As Man Of Steel is a reboot, the story is somewhat different this time around. As such, I will give you a run down, but I'll try to keep it brief. *Be warned that there are spoilers from here on out* We open on the planet Krypton, and are given insight into the first natural birth the planet has seen in some time; the birth of Kal-El to Jor-El and Lara. The planet is on the verge of collapse, literally, and not wanting all their hard work to go to waste, Jor-El plots to send Kal-El to earth, having embedded a code in his genes that will preserve the Kryptonian race. Meanwhile, power mad General Zod overthrows the council of Krypton, believing he can save the planet. Jor-El manages to complete his mission to send Kal-El to earth, but pays for his disloyalty to Zod with his life. Zod is captured and brought before the remaining council members who imprison him and his team in the Phantom Zone. Back on earth we see a grown Kal-El as he tries to make his way in the world, he flits from place to place under different names, any time he does something heroic and is close to being discovered, he moves on. We also see his life as a boy, being brought up as Clark by Martha and Jonathan Kent in flashbacks. Clark discovers a ship in the ice in the arctic and takes a job with the salvage team so that he can take a closer look, believing it may be from his home planet. Once on board Clark activates a hologram of Jor-El who tells him about his origins. Little does Clark know that when he activates the ships programming, it sends a homing beacon to other Kryptonian vessels and draws them to earth. Meaning that Zod and all those who were imprisoned with him are making their way to earth, with vengeance on their minds.
I will preface what I'm about to say by stating that while I am a fan of Superman: The Movie, I tried really hard not to compare Man Of Steel to that film. Despite the fact that they are both origin stories, they are very different beasts, and tell very different stories of very different men. The only similarities really are the character names.
That being said, I didn't feel like the changes made to the story, or to the characters, were to the benefit of this film, or the Superman franchise overall. When Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster created Superman they wanted him to be an immigrant, as they were, an outsider. I believe that the reason they gave him human parents was to allow them to instill in him a sense of humanity, of what's right and wrong, good and bad and so on. The audience can't connect to a superhuman alien, but they sure as hell can connect to a boy from Kansas, who's been brought up well and wants to believe in the goodness of people, who grows up to work in the big, bad city and falls in love with a girl who's out of his league. We can connect to that because on some level we've all been Clark, we've all experienced the things he has. The problem here is that we don't ever really meet adult Clark, we see childhood Clark and teenage Clark in flashbacks, but as an adult we meet the drifter with no name who happens to have super strength and can do weird lazer things with his eyes. We don't get to know the human Clark before we get the alter ego, and more importantly neither does Lois. She meets drifter Clark and immediately is presented with his super powers. At no point in this movie does she not know who he really is. And I just couldn't get on board with that.
The other thing I had massive issues with were the fight scenes at the end of the movie. There were way too many of them and they're all really similar, so you just feel like you're watching one gigantic fight, which gets boring and repetitive. Of the majority of reviews I have read, everyone seems to think the fight scenes are good because there was no action in the last film (Superman Returns - a film I happened to think was not all that bad). But what everyone seems to be forgetting is that Clark is supposed to be a peaceful person, he's been brought up to use diplomacy, not his strength. He's not the guy who beats the crap out of everyone with no regard to the fallout. And fallout there is. There is so much destruction caused by the fights, and Clark, Kal-El, whatever you want to call him, doesn't seem to care. So in turn, the audience doesn't really care.
And what was with all the metallic shape shifting stuff? I felt like I was watching The Matrix, not Superman. Oh and then Morpheus appeared... It was just all wrong.
The one thing I did like were the flashback scenes. I thought Kevin Costner and Diane Lane were well cast as Jonathan and Martha Kent and that those scenes added much needed weight. But those scenes felt so disjointed because we only saw them in flashbacks. I wish it had been better. Cavill, Adams, Crowe, even Michael Shannon, who I didn't know until recently and who I've now seen in three films in as many weeks, were all decent. I just wish it had been a movie more deserving of them.
I think if I'd never seen a Superman movie and knew nothing about the story, I'd have thought it was passable. But I have and I do and as such, it just wasn't for me. 4 out of 10.
Viewing Date - 15th June 2013
UK Release Date - 12th June 2013
Cast Overview:
Henry Cavill ~ Clark Kent/Kal-El
Amy Adams ~ Lois Lane
Diane Lane ~ Martha Kent
Kevin Costner ~ Jonathan Kent
Russell Crowe ~ Jor-El
Ayelet Zurer ~ Lara Lor-Van
Michael Shannon ~ General Zod
Antje Traue ~ Faora-Ul
Harry Lennix ~ General Swanwick
Richard Schiff ~ Dr Emil Hamilton
Christopher Meloni ~ Colonel Nathan Hardy
Laurence Fishburne ~ Perry White
Director ~ Zack Snyder
Writer(s) ~ David S Goyer (Screenplay and Story), Christopher Nolan (Story), Jerry Siegel (Superman Created By) and Joe Shuster (Superman Created By)
Love this review. LOVE it.
ReplyDeleteI re-read it yesterday and thought much the same.
ReplyDelete